Summary: Budget 2026 promises greater competition in Canadian banking, but more lenders will not necessarily mean more Canadians gaining access to credit. With an estimated 35.3% of Canadians considered credit-invisible, the industry’s greatest growth opportunity may lie beyond conventional credit scores. Advances in alternative-data underwriting are demonstrating that lenders can reach underserved borrowers without necessarily increasing risk. The challenge now is ensuring Canada’s emerging consumer-driven banking framework makes financial inclusion an explicit, measurable objective.
Competition Without Inclusion Is Only Half a Reform
On November 5, the federal budget made competition in financial services a national priority. Budget 2026 proposes a new competition objective for OSFI, a one-year clock on decisions for new bank applications, and more room for challenger banks and credit unions to grow. More lenders, in other words. What it leaves open is who those lenders will actually go after.
Here is the trouble with the obvious answer. A new lender is not going to win over people who already have a credit score. You cannot beat the incumbents on price alone, and switching costs push the customer the other way. The real opening is the market the Canadian Lenders Association (CLA) has spent years documenting: the Canadians our credit system cannot see.
The CLA puts the credit-invisible share of Canadians at 35.3%, almost twice the American rate. Consider the newcomer who arrives with ten years of clean financial history that no Canadian credit bureau can read. Or the contractor whose steady income never appears on a T4. Or the young adult who has not had time to build a credit record. On many First Nations reserves, restrictions under the Indian Act also complicate the use of property as loan security.
These borrowers are not necessarily high risk. They are often declined because conventional credit systems cannot adequately assess them. That is a very different problem.
The opportunity is to lend to more of these Canadians without taking on disproportionate risk. Research increasingly suggests that alternative data, including bank transactions, cash flow, rent and utility payments, can improve repayment predictions beyond conventional credit scores alone.
A 2026 study published in Management Science found that conventional models could wrongly reject between 15% and 30% of borrowers approved by an alternative-data model, despite those borrowers subsequently demonstrating low default rates.
The commercial implications are becoming difficult to ignore. In July, TD Bank introduced alternative-data scoring across approximately 5,500 auto dealerships through Trust Science. TD is among the world’s globally systemically important banks, as designated by the Financial Stability Board. Its adoption demonstrates that alternative underwriting is moving into mainstream financial services.
Yet regulatory ambition has not fully caught up with technological capability.
In August, I submitted recommendations to Finance Canada concerning its proposed Consumer-Driven Banking Regulations. The framework identifies three objectives: competition and growth, consumer well-being, and safety and soundness. Financial inclusion is conspicuously absent as a standalone objective.
It appeared in Budget 2025, but Budget 2026 no longer gives it the same prominence. For all the discussion of competition, the proposed framework does not explicitly establish improved access to credit as a measure of success.
This omission matters. What governments do not measure, they rarely manage. Five years from now, Canada could have a more sophisticated financial-data infrastructure without knowing whether it has helped previously excluded borrowers secure credit. We risk moving the same information through better technology while leaving the same people outside the system.
There is also a competitive dimension. American housing regulators have opened mortgage underwriting to an additional credit-scoring model, challenging the dominance of incumbent scoring systems. Canada need not replicate the American approach, but it should ensure its own regulations allow domestic innovators to compete rather than entrench established providers.
Finance Canada’s regulatory analysis estimates approximately $13.2 billion in benefits over ten years, representing more than thirty dollars in benefits for every dollar of costs. Yet the economic opportunity could be greater if consumer-driven banking also expands access to responsible credit.
The remedy is straightforward: make financial inclusion an explicit regulatory objective, establish measurable indicators and publish progress against them.
Although the formal consultation period has closed, the regulations are not yet final. The CLA and its members have an opportunity to reinforce this message as the framework takes shape.
I have made the case in Trust Science’s submission. It will carry greater weight if the broader lending industry speaks with one voice.
A credit system capable of seeing the Canadians it currently overlooks is not simply a social-policy achievement. It represents a larger addressable market, more effective competition and a fairer financial system.
The next generation of lending growth will not come simply from adding more lenders. It will come from recognizing more creditworthy borrowers.
Five Key Takeaways for Canadian Lenders
- Competition must translate into access. Budget 2026 encourages new banking entrants, but greater competition alone will not guarantee better credit access for underserved Canadians.
- Credit invisibility represents a major commercial opportunity. The CLA estimates that 35.3% of Canadians are credit-invisible, highlighting the limitations of traditional credit assessment.
- Alternative data can expand responsible lending. Cash-flow information, banking transactions and payment histories can help identify creditworthy borrowers who conventional models overlook.
- Regulation should encourage Canadian innovation. Consumer-driven banking rules should allow domestic credit-scoring and underwriting providers to compete alongside established incumbents.
- Financial inclusion must be measurable. The CLA and its members should advocate for explicit inclusion objectives, performance indicators and public reporting within Canada’s emerging regulatory framework.
About the Author
Evan Chrapko is the founder and CEO of Trust Science, an Edmonton-based AI-powered credit bureau and credit-scoring provider with patents internationally. Trust Science has submitted formal comments to Finance Canada concerning the proposed Consumer-Driven Banking Regulations.