As Canadians Vote, Financial Innovation Hangs in the Balance

 
Abstract: As Canadians head to the polls, the future of the country’s financial system hangs in the balance. Despite rapid advances in fintech, open banking, and digital credit globally, Canada’s regulatory framework remains outdated, constraining innovation and limiting consumer access to affordable financial products. Urgent reforms are needed to modernize credit regulation, strengthen anti-money laundering oversight, combat fraud, update credit reporting, and establish clear standards for sustainable finance. Without decisive action, Canada risks falling behind in building a dynamic, inclusive, and globally competitive economy. The next federal government must lead this transformation.

Today, Canadians head to the polls to decide the country’s political future. Yet whichever party claims power tonight will inherit a financial system increasingly out of step with the modern economy. Without serious reform, Canada risks preserving an outdated framework that serves neither today’s consumers nor tomorrow’s innovators.

While fintech investment has soared globally and digital-first banking has become the norm, Canada’s regulatory structure remains rooted in a bricks-and-mortar era. Rules designed for traditional banking still govern an economy now shaped by real-time payments, decentralized finance, and embedded credit products. Ottawa’s halting rollout of open banking—still incomplete after years of consultations—is only the most visible sign of the need for modernization.

The costs of delay are real. According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, one in four Canadians is financially vulnerable, relying on credit products to bridge gaps between income and expenses. Yet access to responsible credit remains constrained. Many newer lenders—especially those serving non-prime borrowers—face regulatory burdens designed for multinational banks, not nimble domestic innovators. In practice, this means fewer affordable options and higher borrowing costs for Canadians.

The next federal government must move beyond incrementalism. A proportionate, risk-based approach to credit regulation is urgently needed—one that protects consumers from predatory practices without choking access to essential financial services. Reform must reflect the full diversity of Canada’s credit market, not flatten it with one-size-fits-all rules.

Updating Canada’s anti-money laundering (AML) framework must also be a priority. Current rules, built for a traditional banking environment, increasingly fail to account for the complexity of digital lending and embedded finance. Reform must clarify compliance obligations, reduce ambiguity, and ensure oversight is proportional to actual risk—not simply layered on indiscriminately. A smarter AML regime would bolster both consumer protection and innovation without stifling responsible growth.

At the same time, fraud in sectors such as auto lending is rising sharply. Disparate regulatory frameworks and limited coordination among lenders, dealers, and enforcement agencies allow fraud risks to fester. A stronger national focus on real-time data sharing and collaboration is essential to protecting consumers and preserving market confidence.

Canada’s credit reporting system also demands modernization. Canadians still face long delays in disputing errors, limited portability of financial records, and little transparency in how decisions are made. Other countries have moved to strengthen consumer rights and promote financial data mobility; Canada must follow if it hopes to support economic resilience and mobility.

Meanwhile, standards for green and sustainable finance remain fragmented. As capital increasingly flows toward ESG-labelled products, the lack of enforceable verification standards risks undermining genuine progress. Without clear, measurable criteria, responsible lenders and investors face an uneven playing field—and consumers face growing confusion.

Canada’s financial sector sits at a crossroads. Policymakers can either enable a dynamic, inclusive economy by creating frameworks that welcome responsible innovation—or risk entrenching outdated systems that limit access, slow competition, and hinder growth. In an era where economic competitiveness is increasingly tied to digital leadership, Canada cannot afford inertia.

Throughout this campaign, political leaders have spoken of affordability, prosperity, and fairness. Achieving any of those goals will require a financial system that is not only stable, but modern, open, and globally competitive. Whoever forms the government tonight must be ready to lead that transformation.

Sign up for the CLA 2025 Summit Series